Home arrow Read arrow Stories arrow The Choice arrow Articles arrow Stories 

The Choice Print
Written by Chris Howe   
Wednesday, 27 January 2010

Having learned of the life that their unborn child will have because of a genetic deletion, Chris Howe and his wife are forced to make a harrowing decision.

"Can you see the monitor?" the nurse asks. "No," I lie. The nurse nods and ceases adjusting the display.

I hold my wife's hand, stealing glimpses at the monitor. The procedure is very simple. A quick injection into the thigh to sedate. It is important there is no movement during the procedure. I, punishing myself, secretly watch the display.

On the monitor I see a needle carefully pierce the heart wall, injecting a solution. There is no delay. The heart stops immediately. My wife cries. I join her. Inside, our daughter, a week away from being born, shifts slightly. She is unaware of the death of her brother moments before and centimetres away.

At 34 weeks, it's a late termination. Born six days later along with his sister, Bethany, Alfred is 20 grams heavier than Beth at birth. Together, they weigh exactly five kilograms.

I'm not a great man. I may not even be a good man. I know in some eyes, I'm as evil as it gets. This story isn't fun or easy to tell. It was hard to live, and it still haunts me.

At 20 weeks we'd received the best news ever - our twins were a boy and girl. We already had a daughter and it was exactly what we wanted. Two daughters and a son. I'd have a son. A son. It's a big deal for a fella. I won't lie, I was pretty chuffed.

My son would live for 14 more weeks.

It rolled from a single 'indicator' at 24 weeks to genetic tests uncovering a deletion at 32 weeks. "How bad is that?" I asked the geneticist. "It's never good," he responded. It was 23 December, 2008.

For the next few hours we discussed his condition. He'd look normal. He'd live almost as long as his sister, with a small chance of an early death from a heart condition. He wouldn't walk before six years of age, and he'd never talk. He'd be unable to express himself or to tell the difference between loved ones and strangers. Kisses could become vicious bites due to low impulse control. He'd be violent and would need to be kept away from children his own age. Inappropriate approaches to strangers during puberty were likely.

He'd never live an independent life. He'd require care from birth to death.

Sometimes, the decision to abort is almost made for us. The defect means the child won't survive, or the mother's life is at risk, or both. Without diminishing the horror for the parents, it can simply be tragically unavoidable. But not in the case of Fred. We had to ask the hard questions. Questions that make you seem like a villain for even considering them.

What makes us human? When is a life worth living? Worth ending? How much suffering is bearable? Is avoiding suffering brave or is it cowardice? When is abortion justified?

Should Fred be born, my wife would never return to work. My daughters would always come second. Some basic research online and asking friends in health roles showed a high chance of divorce before my son was a teenager, the stress of care literally tearing our family apart. Every news article we read showed little or no government support, with charities closing their doors. The doctors were encouraging about support; the real life carers we spoke to, not so much.

I'd never support killing a born child on any grounds. Yet here I was, suggesting death for a child almost born. I may not be a good man, but I'm a husband and a father. Had we not known, I'd be living with Fred's condition today; but we take the tests so we can act on the information received.

So, let a bad man say the words that will condemn me: Fred's life would have been less than human. It would have been filled with love, yes, but mostly loneliness, confusion, pain and frustration. The risk to my marriage and the welfare of my daughters was too much. I chose to minimise suffering. For my wife, for my daughters, for myself and most of all for Fred, I chose abortion. It was a choice of love.

I regret having to make the decision, but I'll never regret the decision itself. That said, I miss him in my life. At least I have Bethany, while many parents have nothing. A few weeks ago I held her, six days before her birthday, a little tighter on that day.

 

Comment Form

We have detected that you're not a registered member, or you've not logged in.

Register your FREE account now to leave your own comment and help us build a great online community for parents across Australia.



Discuss (22 posts)
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 19:01:15
As the author of this article, I'd also like to add another two cents: abortion in NSW is illegal. It shouldn't be. This journey is terrible enough with the additional hurdle of 'proving' the termination is required.
More than anything about this journey, I'm angry at the suggestion a patient in NSW should travel to Victoria to recieve medical care.
#4209
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 19:40:53
What an amazing man!

Your daughter is blessed to have a father like you, a father that cares so deeply and makes the bravest, hardest decisions to ensure her life is a good one, a father that cares so much for his unborn son that he ensures he does not have a life filled with pain and sorrow.

You have made the decision to put every single member of your family first and NO ONE can stand in judgement of that.
#4210
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 19:54:17
So beautifully written. A decision that no one should ever have to go through. I agree with Sharpest Pencil that absolutely no one can ever be judgemental of what you as parents had to decide for your son and the rest of your family.

I actually didn't know that abortion was illegal in NSW. For whatever reason someone needs to consider abortion it should be available legally and without judgement. As if you weren't already going through enough, to be told you have to travel to another state is unthinkable.

Thank you for sharing your story.
#4211
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 20:20:10
Chris,
What a moving, beautifully written and brave piece. As a parent who has had to make a similar decision I *get* it. It hurts and it sucks and there is no getting around the horror of it. Living though it - scarred to your soul but with the unique gifts that brief glimpses of hell can provide - is our lifelong challenge. I wish only love to you, your wife and your daughters.
You honour Fred by remembering him. You are a good man.
#4212
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 20:38:17
I felt strongly enough, after reading this article, to sign up to Webchild so I could comment. After signing up, I sat this little white box in the middle of my screen to make a comment and now, I'm not sure what to say. I am speechless (for those who know me, this does not happen often).

Chris, you and your wife are the strongest people I know, have read about or even heard of! I respect your decision more than I can put into words. I cannot imagine being in your situation. I can only hope that, should I one day find myself in a similar situation, I have as much courage as you.
#4213
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 20:48:41
I read this and struggled to keep the lump in my throat and tears in my eyes from turning into heaving sobs (while looking after my own kids). It was so beautifully written and I wish the author & his family much love & strength. I cannot begin to imagine what it took to go through this, to make the decision, and also to share it with all of us.
#4214
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 22:01:28
Amazing story, amazing strength.
Some choices are too enormous to have to make, as a fellow parent who had the same terrible choice, I admire your bravery in speaking about it, and framing it with so much intelligence and love. well done!
#4216
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 22:23:51
An awful decision to have to make and extremely brave of you to write about it. By letting Fred go you and your wife quite possibly 'saved' the lives of your daughters in so many meanings of the word. I have no doubt that their lives are filled with love and also with attention that they would not have received as much of otherwise.
#4217
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 22:35:23
This is a heartbreaking story. I can't even put into words what I want to say. You and your wife were brave and strong and wise and thoughtful, a powerful combination. Judgment doesn't belong anywhere near issues like this. When good people face tough decisions the only appropriate human response is support. I hope you both had that and continue to get it.
#4218
The Choice
Jan 26 2010 22:41:58
Wow, Chris. Thank you for the open and honest story. My wife and I too had to make a similar decision for different reasons, and it still stays with me today. I agree with you that we did feel like criminals operating outside of the traditional NSW health system, and think abortion does need to be re-evaluated again.

Thank you for 'manning up' to talk about the toughest of decisions with us all.
#4219
The Choice
Jan 27 2010 02:02:29
Life's hardest choices are not between good and evil: they are much more complicated than that. Your decision to fulfil your role as husband, father and protector to your family has put you in a difficult position. Open to criticism regardless of your choice, you have chosen what you celibte to be right for your family. You will be a father all of your children will be able to honour. A courageous decision.
#4222
Re:The Choice
Jan 27 2010 03:44:40
Life is often unfair. You were dealt a dud card and you put your family first. It was a considered decision and one that has the least adverse impact. For this you have made the right one.
Every day will get easier. Gold bless all of you.
#4223
The Choice
Jan 27 2010 03:54:18
That you made "a choice of love" is apparent in every word you have written. Thank you for sharing your family's story.
#4224
Re:The Choice
Jan 27 2010 06:30:59
Well thanks for all the kind comments everyone. My wife and I have been reading them throughout the day and it's been great.
#4225
The Choice
Jan 28 2010 06:20:48
You've expressed your despair with an eloquence that has brought some readers to tears. It's a decision I am thankful I've never had to face, and no-one can say how they would react if they have not been in that position. It's heart-achingly tortuous that as parents we now have the power of life and death over our own children. Either way, there is both pain and joy in the journey. More of the joy to you and your family.
#4226
The Choice
Jan 31 2010 04:56:45
I've had trouble working out exactly what I want to say in response to your brave story. Thank you for sharing it with us - I imagine writing this was almost as hard as making the choice itself.

Yours was a courageous decision - one I'm sure that will live with you both for the rest of your lives.
#4227
The Choice
Feb 05 2010 06:50:08
I read this a few days ago and have spent alot of time pondering this incredibly sad story. I absolutely do not know what i would do if faced with this awful set of circumstances. I have no clue. I think that's why I remained wordless because every way I thought about it, it was just awful.
So I'm sorry.
I'm sorry for the awful decision you had to make. I'm sorry about all of it.
#4238
The Choice
Feb 05 2010 08:08:20
I can't comment on what you went through, because I don't have children myself, but it moved me to tears.

For the record to others though, abortion is NOT illegal in NSW. The requirement to prove 'necessity' is barely a formality, involving a nurse asking almost rhetorically "Do you feel incapable of providing adequately for a child?". In the scheme of the entire termination experience, I barely noticed those words or my inevitable and expected response. It is as legal and safe as it could possibly be, hope to hell the rabid god-botherers stay out of it (*cough* Abbott).
#4239
Re:The Choice
Feb 05 2010 08:30:59
Pussinboots,
Abortion is illegal in NSW. Abortion is only legal in ACT and Victoria. The requirement to prove necessity after 20 weeks is anything but a formality. It takes weeks, days of interviews and lots and lots of stress.

See this article: http://www.smh.com.au/national/doctors-vetoed-on-lateterm-abortion-20091023-hdcb.html

Same hospital, similar scenario except that Fred would have lived. Had those hospital administrators declined, Fred would be living in pain today, my wife wouldn't be back at work Beth would be the forgotten child "Thank God she's so good and quiet" we'd say, while ignoring her.

Also recently, a couple in Queensland were charged for having an abortion. http://www.smh.com.au/national/right-to-choose-abortion-wins-strong-support-20091004-ghxd.html

A women's right to chose before 20 weeks shouldn't need any 'requirements'. After 20 weeks, as in Victoria, if two doctors concur the abortion can go ahead.

We need a debate in NSW. The majority of Australians support a woman's right to choose. Does my story help? Probably not, but a comment like that can't pass.
#4240
The Choice
Feb 06 2010 03:54:49
Sorry, I don't mean to nitpick, I meant abortion in general - in the situation of over 20 weeks I don't know how the concept of lawful is tested (obviously BADLY). I know the Levine decision of 1971 interpreted abortion as being legal on the basis of the mental and physical health of the mother, but that the law doesn't define what is lawful and unlawful as such, so it is unfortunately left to a motley and devastatingly complicated process of medical and legal interpretation - hence your harrowing tale. According to the 1971 decision two doctor's opinions arent't required, so I'm not sure why a Review committee even exists! I imagine it is in place to reduce liability on the hospital system - it is completely wrong you should have to face that when it isn't supported by legislation, precedent, common law or common sense.

I'm mad for what you had to go through. The medical beauracracy should not be allowed to run unchecked while the law lags behind. The suggestion someone should go to Victoria shows only that the medical system wants to avoid litigation, and Victoria's laws have obviously evolved to plug the holes of interpretation NSW is still subject to.

Who is fighting for this? I was worried about the Queensland couple, now I'm even more concerned.
#4241
Re:The Choice
Feb 06 2010 08:48:17
I am fighting for this! Groups like ProChoiceNSW are fighting for this!

You can't blame the medical system. It's the law that is the crock. This is taken from the SMH article: "NSW Health guidelines on terminations after 20 weeks' gestation call for an assessment to be made by a multi-disciplinary team. ... specialists told the Herald they feared a clampdown on abortion within state public hospitals. The NSW Government was anxious to avoid a backlash from people opposed to abortion generally or to late-term procedures, they said."

In 2006 a doctor in NSW was convicted because she couldn't prove she asked the question about wellbeing. The approach by the Doctors at the Royal Hospital for Women and their administrators are reasonable considering this conviction. Relying on 'the question' as a safe middle ground is not enough. As you say, the law is lagging behind. We must push for legalisation.

In the meantime, you hope rabid 'god-bothers' say out of it. You mention Abbot - he's the alternative Prime Minister of the country. He considers me a murderer. Well, actually he only considers my wife a murderer if you look at what he said which was "We have a bizarre double standard in this country where someone who kills a pregnant woman's baby is guilty of murder but a woman who aborts an unborn baby is simply exercising choice." I must have "mates benefits". The Doctors who performed the operation though, probably don't.

In the meantime, The Liberals in NSW are going to win the next election. While Barry O'Farrell may be a moderate (he even sent me a sympathetic message on Twitter regarding this article) others like David Clarke are not. To keep the government running, who can say what compromises Barry would need to make to keep the Christian Right in check?

So get mad.
#4243
The Choice
Feb 26 2010 05:47:26
I am so very sorry Chris, I cannot imagine that kind of agony for you and your wife. I agree with jfiander- I joined simply to say this to you and it's taken me forever to think what to say, I wish you your family the very best and I hope over time it feels a little less raw and cruel for you both.
#4261
< Prev   Next >

Login

Have an account? Login
Don't have an account? Register
Lost Password?
Playgroup Australia

Calendar

  calendar.pngCheck out what's happening near you in our up-to-date calendar!

Directory

directory.pngLooking to buy, sell or trade something?

Reader Offers

reader-offers.pngYour chance to win some great prizes.

Store

shopping.pngBrowse our Store for magazine subscriptions, family organisers and more...