Home arrow Read arrow Web Editor’s Blog arrow The Pluses Of Division arrow Articles arrow Web Editor's Blog 

The Pluses Of Division Print
Written by Siobhan McMahon   
Friday, 23 October 2009

This week marks my 17th wedding anniversary; or rather, it would were it not for the fact that the eighth anniversary of our separation was earlier this month. And lately I've been thinking that, all things considered, our divorce has been good for all concerned - including the children.

The girls were very young when my 'husband and I separated: Katie was three years old and Maddie only one-and-a-half. The bright side of this is that they don't remember us being together; they have no before-and-after memories to compare. As far as they're concerned, this is the way it's always been. The benefit of this is that they were spared the trauma of the upheaval that divorce brings; they were so dependent on me at those early ages that their father's weekday absence went largely unnoticed, and then it became normal.

Conventional wisdom is that divorce is terrible for children. The possible and oft-quoted consequences of divorce for children include increased risks of poverty, depression, drug abuse and suicide. The message is that divorce is all-round bad news and you should do everything you can to stay with your partner for the sake of the children.

Bunkum. As a parent who is not only divorced, but the child of divorced parents, I've amassed a bit of knowledge in this area, and I'm calling the bluff of these doomsayers, many of whom have a moralistic barrow to push.

In 2008 in Australia, there were more than 43,000 children whose parents divorced. It's time somebody listed some of the possible beneficial outcomes for these children.

First of all, there's the big, glaring potential positive (or, as one friend put it, a non-negative): removal from a scene of conflict. When a marriage involves constant arguing, or, even worse, physical or sexual abuse, removal from that environment is obviously a huge plus. Even for very young children, no longer spending their evenings waiting for the yelling to start is an enormous improvement.

Secondly, if the parents are able to build an effective co-parenting relationship, the children can see how you can 'work' with somebody even when you don't particularly want to. Conflict resolution, negotiation and compromise, patience, common (or uncommon) civility, and a good deal of biting one's tongue - these are all called upon regularly by many divorced parents who are sharing the responsibility of looking after their children. When the children are adults, they will reflect on how their parents put the needs of their children for a stable parenting structure above their own anger and hurt. Top-notch role-modelling in anybody's book, surely.

Next, if and when the parents start dating, the children will be able to observe first-hand how an adult goes about forming new relationships, and if necessary, dissolving them. I have had one 'public' relationship (i.e. involving the children and my broader family) since my divorce, and my daughters were keenly interested in the process of that relationship. Naturally they were full of questions during the ebb and flow of the romance, and while I didn't share with them all the details that I told my close friends, they did learn things from my relationship.

If a parent then re-partners, that relationship holds the promise of a whole new group of people to love and nurture the children. I can personally attest to this one: when my father remarried 25 years ago, I gained a loving stepmother and my eventual children a grandmother who is, simply, the best. Children can benefit from the extra parents, grandparents, siblings, aunts, uncles and cousins who might come with the blended family package.

The separation of households has many benefits for children. They get to experience more than one way of living; even when the two households are similar from a cultural and moral perspective, the inevitable difference in rules and outlooks between the two homes can demonstrate that there is more than one way in which life can be lived. Similarly, the parents get to parent their own way; a friend of mine who is a separated father says he enjoys being able to challenge his sons without his ex-wife's 'mollycoddling', and he's fairly certain she similarly enjoys her freedom from his influence.

I think the increased amount of time that the children spend alone with one or other of their parents results in more 'quality time' with that parent. When I spent weekends at my father's house as a child, I felt that I received more of his attention than I did when we lived together before he separated from my mother. When a parent is living with a child on a daily basis, weekends can easily get swallowed up by chores and activities that are not centred on the child; but when a parent only gets every second weekend, or a periodical visit during the holidays, they are more likely to put aside the everyday to focus on spending time with their child. My father cherished the time we had together and to this day I think our relationship benefits from that. Similarly, on the weekends the girls are with me, I am able to spend time with them without dividing my attention between them and another adult, or consulting another person's preferences on what we should do with our time. We choose, and we have fun doing what we want to do, just the three of us.

So much for the great big positives that children can experience after a divorce. Now, let's look at some of the more trivial, fun benefits.

Here's one that children would probably put at the top on their list: doubling up on presents and parties. Instead of getting Christmas/birthday/whatever presents from 'Mum and Dad', they get gifts from both parents - not to mention extras from all those new members of their family if their parent re-partners! Ditto on the celebrations; we have a Christmas lunch with my family and the girls then have a Christmas lunch with their father's family (we take it in turns to get the actual day); they'll have a birthday party with me, then a movie and dinner, or something similar, with their dad. Bonus!

Travel is another possible plus. If one of the parents moves away, the children may be able to travel to visit them. The daughter of a friend of mine travels to Germany every couple of years to visit her father; for my own children, their father lives in a town that most people only visit for their holidays, but they get to spend every second weekend there.

Last, and probably most trivial in this non-exhaustive list, is a skill that the girls have developed at an early age as a result of spending every second weekend at Dad's house - the ability to pack a bag. Given some basic information (number of days, weather forecast, any special events), my daughters can pack bags for a visit to their dad's pretty much single-handedly, and (aside from Maddie's unfortunate tendency to always forget either her swimmers or her PJs) they do a pretty good job at it. When they become world-travellers (yet to happen to me but I have hopes for them), this will be a handy skill.

All of these benefits are of course contingent upon the circumstances of the divorce, and whether the parents are able to put their children's need for stability above their own feelings. And rest assured that I am not advocating divorce in order to get extra prezzies; however for anybody who is currently going through a divorce or contemplating one, it's nice to know that it can turn out okay.

What do you think? Am I dismissing those negative effects too easily, or are there positives I've missed? Tell us your thoughts in the comments below.

A

Alison Sainsbury
Web Editor

The Department of Human Services has recently launched a website to help families find information to help with the emotional, financial and legal issues they face during separation. It has information on support products and services for partners, children, grandparents and people affected by family violence.

 

Comment Form

We have detected that you're not a registered member, or you've not logged in.

Register your FREE account now to leave your own comment and help us build a great online community for parents across Australia.



Discuss (8 posts)
The Pluses Of Division
Oct 24 2009 04:21:58
Here's a piece about a little guy who definitely sees the pluses of division http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/entertainment/music/kaseys-kids-a-chip-off-the-old-block/story-e6frexl9-1225790576139
In the hard copy of the Tele today they had some of the lyrics which included:
'I have two houses, lucky me
At my Mum's I go to bed at eight
At my Dad's I sometimes stay up late
At my Mum's I have a little brother of my own
My Dad's house has a pool, a dog named Emmy Lou
And all my bedrooms walls are painted blue"
I think it's very cute.
#4035
The Pluses Of Division
Oct 25 2009 09:27:17
Another great blog, Alison. You are so right to list the pluses. Not that anyone in their right mind would choose divorce over a happy 'together' family situation, but the choice of separation over stress, conflict and misery is far preferable in my view. My ex and I have managed to become good frends again, now that we have our own space and independence, and aren't worn out from the constant stress of trying to live together - which was never going to work long-term. I'm sure it is much better for our kids. They seem pretty happy - and they get double the holidays too!

I grew up with parents that stayed together 'for the children'. There wasn't a lot of direct conflict - it was more a non-communicative, resentful, martyrish type of situation and nothing ever got resolved.

I hope my kids will grow up to know that if somthing's not working it's better to acknowledge that and devise a better way of living, rather than to plod along feeling trapped and resentful.
#4037
The Pluses Of Division
Oct 26 2009 01:06:11
Hi!
Divorce is the only real answer when home life is stressed. Parents should seriously consider splitting up if they are negatively impacting their kids. A dysfunctional relationship is no role model for a child. Remember that children tend to copy what they see...
My parents divorced after many years of tension, drama and acrimony and it was a RELIEF! Fortunately, we learned how to manage relationships and their breakdowns as well as trust and responsibility.
So 'staying together for the kids' is, in my opinion, an excuse for parents who are unwilling to face the facts!
On the other hand, if a relationship can be righted, give it all the effort you can because the right marriage/relationship has wonderful gifts.

Gail G
#4039
The Pluses Of Division
Oct 26 2009 02:00:20
Hi Alison - My ex and I divorced when my twins were three and our eldest was just 6. I do have friends envious of getting my fortnighly weekend off and this has helped to develop a wonderful new relationship and be able to get some real adult relationship time. Whilst the kids have a fabulous life and love the double ups and extra family and friends we bring into their lives now, my oldest now 12, does find the weekends when not at home less desirable away from most of her "things". They were so young that they didn't see how sad I was and their lives are so great now (just returned from round world trip recently with there stepfather and I as an example) that it can be hard for them to understand the "why" and some times they do talk about us all living together! My x and I work very hard to keep a great firendly relationship and our home is always open for him to visit any time. I agree that kids from divorced families should not be tagged as disadvantaged or likely to end up in drug or other poor circumstances - nonsense. Both my parents came from divorced familes and they lead positive happy lives and made great contributions to our community. They have been married to one another for over 50 years! We should not put labels and preconceived bad outcomes upon divorced children or burden divorced parents with the guilt of being potentialy responsible for a sad outcome. Lets spend all out energy with the kids and help them lead great positive lives.
#4042
The Pluses Of Division
Oct 26 2009 20:25:31
I really enjoyed reading your piece on divorce Alison.

I too am the child of divorced parents, but my brother and I were adults when our parents separated. I can remember only a few times when they were happy together, but lots of times when they weren't. I remember them fighting when they thought we were asleep. They showed me what an unhealthy relationship was, so when I realised I was in one I knew I needed to get out before it turned into 20+ years of arguing.

I left my first husband. We didn't have children so once our belongings were split up we went our separate ways. I don't have any contact with him now almost five years down the track, but I do have an understanding of a good, loving relationship with a wonderful man. We have two happy children who will grow up seeing how a good relationship works.

I agree, there are upsides to divorce.

Johanna
#4044
The Pluses Of Division
Nov 01 2009 16:54:20
Thank you for your article. I am currently going through a separation and am really pleased to hear a positive article about divorce and kids. The doom and gloom gets a bit much sometimes.
#4054
The Pluses Of Division
Nov 01 2009 16:54:42
Thank you for your article. I am currently going through a separation and am really pleased to hear a positive article about divorce and kids. The doom and gloom gets a bit much sometimes.
#4055
The Pluses Of Division
Nov 05 2009 01:15:01
As a child from divorced parents you are definately not living in reality if you think that what the child doesn't have a memory of, they wont miss! Yes I agree that it is better for children to live in a harmonious house rather than one of upheaval. But have you ever stopped to consider what it is like to not have that constant father figure around?

All my life I have looked for that father figure. I was 5 years old when my parents divorced and although I too 'don't have memories to compare with' but gee I wish I did. I looked on with anguish and longing at other friends who had a 'mum and dad' at home. So saying that 'what children don't remember they won't miss' is totally unrealistic and quiet selfish of you. If this makes your conscious feel better with your marital breakup than that is good for you. But if you think this is trueful for your children you need to WAKE UP!

My first marriage broke up as it wasn't working and i did not want to bring children into that environment. I'm now married again with a child and I don't forget for 1 second what it is like to grow up in a house without mum and dad. Yes I got to see my dad every second weekend and maybe sporting or school plays, I idolised my father and still do - although he is passed. My parents divorce was bitter and messy and not alot of fun for the kids. Would I have wanted to live in a house like that - no? Did I still long for the 'memories I never had' - Yes!
#4060
< Prev   Next >

Login

Have an account? Login
Don't have an account? Register
Lost Password?

Calendar

  calendar.pngCheck out what's happening near you in our up-to-date calendar!

Directory

directory.pngLooking to buy, sell or trade something?

Reader Offers

reader-offers.pngYour chance to win some great prizes.

Store

shopping.pngBrowse our Store for magazine subscriptions, family organisers and more...